/ ARTICLE: What every Climber should know about their Scaphoid Bones
Is it just me or do all the x-ray images look the same?
A scaphiod fracture ended my climbing career about 8 years ago. I was by no means prolific, but I was climbing indoors a couple of times a week and in the mountains at the weekend fairly often. It was a mountain bike fall that did it for me. I hit probably the last bit of ice of the winter on a flat forest road going hell for leather (having removed my spikes the weekend before...), bike went out from under me and I hit the ground really hard. Got massive bruising on my left hip and a bit of a sore wrist - had to cycle about 20km back home after the fall but didn't think that much of it, other than knowing I'd had a hard fall.
Woke up the next day with swelling in the wrist and restricted movement so went to hospital. X-ray showed a broken scaphoid and they told me it would need an operation to heal properly, where the two bits would be screwed back together. This was all done, was in plaster for about 8 weeks or so and then had physio.
Its not been right since - basically couldn't put any weight on it or pull on it for months and getting my thumb into awkward positions was really uncomfortable, my left arm had wasted a bit too. Climbing just really hurt and after a year or so of trying in the end I just kind of gave up. For the first couple of years, loads of things could trigger pain - if I held a bag wrong, something got twisted round my thumb etc. Day to day now , its not painful as such any more. There is some nerve damage and a dull ache most of the time and only hurts when it gets tweaked or pulled on funny, but it does mean climbing is difficult. I don't miss climbing so badly any more (I say commenting on a climbing website which I visit pretty often!) and have switched over full time to running, but just another story to add on the topic.
The first one looks completely different to me - no crack through the middle of the cashew / scaphoid, and a crack is clearly visible in the other two xrays.
I suspected I was missing something. Can see it now.
From my experience it is not just a fracture of the scaphoid bone that can lead to a grim outcome for the wrist but also damage to the connected ligaments - particularly the scapho-lunate ligament. If you have an injury but X-Ray does not reveal a break try to also get MRI for identifying soft tissue damage such as this. I had a historic injury in this ligament and through lack of diagnosis / treatment now have a SLAC (scapho-lunate advanced collapse) wrist with advanced and painful arthritis for the which the likely outcome is also full fusion. The pain of ctrl-alt-delete is pathetically familiar to me, although satisfying climbing has so far still been possible with some heavy taping.
I wonder if either of the two patients in the article have climbed since their surgery? I would love to know, since it is probably my future. Please pm me if you are reading this, Steve or Neil. Thanks.
Great article - thank you Jeremy and Tim for so kindly sharing your professional knowledge with the climbing community.
That worries me more than a little. 10 years ago, I injured my wrist climbing. My GP suspected I snapped a ligament, I heard and felt a snap while undercutting something with the wrist flexed and lost feeling on the fingers fed by the ulnar nerve for a few days, but would not refer me onwards. It took a couple of years for it to feel strong again and it has not been completely right since. It has a ganglion that comes and goes and cannot flex all the way to 90 degrees without significant pain. I'm not sure how I could go on getting it seen properly at this stage.
Great article as always Jeremy & Tim. Was diagnosed with scaphoid # 2 1/2 years ago which turned out to be a scapho-lunate ligament in the end. Thanks again for advice given in the past and now back to a bit of light climbing again getting the strength back! 👍
Excellent article, clear and informative, many thanks.
Thanks for the good info and advice. But how do you see all of the recommended experienced medics, and get the recommended tests? Go to private sports medicine clinics --which must be expensive. Up here in Scotland it is difficult to even see a NHS GP within a few weeks wait for an appointment, let alone ask for exotic tests. I simply got a phone consultation when I damaged my ankle badly in a mountain bike crash and was worried about a fracture.
This week's Friday Night Video takes us to Bohuslän in south-west Sweden. Hazel Findlay and climbing partner Maddy Cope had heard about the perfect granite cracks in the area for years and recently made the trip over. Hazel manages to find...