topo of new route ?

Isn't that the line of the grade II "land of make believe"?

No. We started at the foot of Peter Pan Direct with the intention of doing it and did the first pitch but my mate saw this line that he thought was worth a go. Was about grade III/IV

It's the line of Peter Pan before it was straightened out by the direct !

It's exactly the line of Land of Make Believe, as marked in the topo in Scottish Winter Climbs. That's the line taken by Rab Anderson and drawn in by him on the topo

It wasnt the 'land of make beleive' there was a team doing it on one of the pictures very close to us. We started on PP Direct and then a tenous line off to the right and back left at the top of PP Direct and certainly about grade III/IV. Thge guidebook shows LoMBelieve further over to the right.

I dont have the MofS Winter guidebook ive got the Alan Kimber Winter Climbs guide published by Cicerone