In reply to CurlyStevo:
> on stanage I found all of these are easier.
> Mississippi Variant (honestly VS IMO)
I think this has always been HVS, of your little list it's the one I found hardest and the only one I'd say is as hard as GNR.
> Dovers Wall Route 2 (maybe a tad easier than GNR)
Gear in and go for it - good holds, steep but over soon.
used to be VS - VS(+) IIRC in the green Stanage guide from 1976, VS 4c in the Paul Nunn guide - upgrade to HVS is reasonable
> Robin Hood's Cave Innominate/Harding's Finish (not the direct start! I found the VS bit on this harder than the HVS bit!)
Superdirect (finish) I think same "story" as Agony Crack.
The VS bit - just up to the cave - I soloed on sight when I was a young lad and years later led it and did the usual "wtf were you thinking when you soloed it". IIRC the tricky bit is the first few moves getting to where the crack starts.
Wouldn't it be boring if we all found the same difficulty in climbs, what would we discuss if everybody agreed on the order in graded lists 😁