In reply to Offwidth:
Five routes were recorded there in the 2000 guide, three dating to the fifties with two added in the eighties. I have no idea if further routes were sent to the CC before and ignored, but I suspect that this is quite likely.
I started writing my miniguide in the early 2000s, naively believing that we were new routing - and in my defence I had a recent and allegedly definitive guidebook in my hand.
Versions have been in circulation since 2002, published in OTE and on Javu, and for something like a decade it was actually downloadable as a pdf direct from the CC website - I see it's been removed from there now. There were many hundreds (probably low thousands) of ascents logged on here, and whenever I went back I met people with printed copies of my guide. But when the latest definitive came out the CC were very uninterested in engaging with me at all and decided to overwrite everything. The descriptions I'd put into the UKC logbooks have gone now too, replaced with 'no description has been submitted...'
I'm over it now - clearly the CC's version will win out - but their dismissive attitude still rankles. So does the fact that I see Tom Last has decided to write 'total bollocks' about my work in the logbook on every route there...