In reply to TobyA:
I think Dan tried to be very fair about fit, but it's inevitable that a glove that doesn't fit is unlikely to review well.
For me, most gloves have fingers that are too long, if the body fits. So dexterity is a problem. So it's nice to read that some gloves have fingers that are 'too short'; I may go and look at them...
I'd also agree that glove sizing is utterly random, and the only way to get a pair that fits is to try them on.
I don't think it's that I have short fingers, more that the webs between them are large, so my fingers can't reach into the gloves... Having Raynaud's, I'm a bit of a glove obsessive, and have dozens of pairs, always looking for 'perfection'. Oddly enough, the best fitting pair I ever had was a pair of Polaris 'Wind Grip' gloves. Sadly, I finished off the Amara fingers trying to follow Haggis up an easy route on Stanage when I was utterly freezing. I know, climbing on grit in gloves... Marginally better than trying to climb with white, waxy, numb fingers...
I have a pair of ACG gloves picked up stupidly cheap in TKM; Schoeller, Gore-tex, Primaloft, Pittards, you name it, they've got it. Sadly, designed for a small elf with long, slender hands. Any elves reading; feel free to make me an offer..