UKC

Climbing....................Middle Class and White?

New Topic
This topic has been archived, and won't accept reply postings.
 coinneach 22 Apr 2005
Is this true?
JoHNY 22 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:

What do you think knob ?
OP coinneach 22 Apr 2005
In reply to JoHNY:

Knob????

I have rarely met either a coloured or working class person at a British crag.
JoHNY 22 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:

Really, everyone i meet in the mountains certainly works for living. They all seem pretty down to earth to me, maybe your talking about wall climbing ?
OP coinneach 22 Apr 2005
In reply to JoHNY:
I don't do walls JoHNY.........As I said I have rarely met a coloured or working class person at a British CRAG
JoHNY 22 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:

Now i know your trolling.
whispers 22 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach: we are working class u obviously dont get out much !!!!!!!!!!!
Dru 23 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:

Yo bro me and me home boys were tinking of cheking out the Stanage flava, use sayin the crags not to popular with the brotherz or summit? innit.
In reply to coinneach:

However can you judge what class someone is from seeing them climb? Is it their baggy dungarees, flat cap and smoking habit? Their regional accent maybe?

I think this class thing is an anachronism anyway. I don't have one so why should anyone else?
brothersoulshine 23 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:

Whether what you're saying is true or not, the real question is - who gives a flying f*ck?
whispers 23 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:WORDS THAT COME TO MIND: are thinks there a cut above every one else and COINNEACH=ass hole or is that where ur head has been
Dru 23 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:

You better believe it, all that disposible income....probably just about every UKC user fits that profile...lots of reasons for this cultural being the main reason blah blah...just look at the recent Lakes case, concerning free guided walks, they were set up to attract ethnic minorities to the park.. but only attracted tight older white middle classes..enough to alienate any minority, so now they have stopped them.....go figure.
 Bruce Hooker 23 Apr 2005
In reply to Dru:

> ....but only attracted tight older white middle classes..enough to alienate any minority, so now they have stopped them.....go figure.

Why do you think this would "alientate a minority", even supposing such a being existed and had a collective conscience capable of reasoning, I'm sure it wouldn't give a damn. Similarly why do you refer to these old codgers as being "tight", if I remember correctly thay had to pay for the walk? Truly "tight" old codgers (like myself for example) wouldn't dream of paying to be taken on a walk.

Back on the subject, this question has been asked before and I can't see any reason to find it offensive to ask the question. I can't remember what the answers were though.
djviper 23 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach: erm dipsh1t joe brown,joe simpson, simon yates,don whillans all the sehffield collective that shared a "house" all working class lads please resurch and return leave any trolling to the experts
 EarlyBird 23 Apr 2005
In reply to djviper:

Wasn't Joe Simpson's dad an army officer? Not an occupation stuffed to the gills with the working class.
cakewalk 23 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:

Definition of white middle class? The frequenters of this forum. All so desperate to appear working class, and grass roots "maaan", but they are all in denial.
uriel 23 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:

dont you think even using the term 'middle class' is outdated circa 1920's? or do you still have a man to do your britches up in the morning and Iron your paper?


Im working class and quite pink

To be middle class nowadays you have to earn 50k+ (see other threads)

Uriel
djviper 23 Apr 2005
In reply to EarlyBird: indeed but joe did slum it in a shared climbing house in shefield if memory serves
Justin 23 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach: 'my daddy's got a Porsche'
djviper 23 Apr 2005
In reply to Justin: thats nothin my daddies got five :~)
 Postmanpat 23 Apr 2005
In reply to cakewalk:
He was also educated at Ampleforth ,"the Catholic Eton" . Nice guy no doubt but hardly working class . But frankly , who gives a shit ?
 Lbos 23 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach: Dunno but every time I have been to the Chew valley, there have been people there that you could shoehorn into the working class stereotype. In fact they are just the type of people you would expect to find in an industrialised area just outside oldham.
In reply to djviper:
> (In reply to EarlyBird) indeed but joe did slum it in a shared climbing house in shefield if memory serves

Yes, I went to a party there once. It was a tip.

climbingdr 23 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:
> Is this true?

I'm white and middle class and I climb with my girlfriend who is japanese and middle class.

nrp
Jonno 23 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:

When I first came on this board about three years ago,I posted
'Climbing...shades of white' which was pretty much in the same vein as your thread.
Climbing IS a white sport,That's an absolute fact.
However,with regard to it being a MC pursuit.Although the majority of climbers are middle class there are still a lot of working class climbers,from which group I would describe myself,out there climbing.
It has to be a cultural thing. After all white men can't dance !
whispers 23 Apr 2005
In reply to Bruce Hooker: mmmmmmm senile dementia comes to mind
mike swann 24 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:
> Is this true?

No, it's butter ollocks

Without really paying much attention (because I'm not interested) there are lots of "ethnic backgrounds" visiting the Swindon wall. As for middle class, well what the hell does that mean anyway?
 Rob Naylor 24 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:
> (In reply to JoHNY)
> I don't do walls JoHNY.........As I said I have rarely met a coloured or working class person at a British CRAG

Dunno about "working class", I don't know how to tell them from looks or a quick chat alone...maybe you have some special "WC antenna" that alerts you?

But I see a fair number of ethnic minority people at crags these days. More often Chinese/ South East Asian or Indian extraction than African/ Afro-Caribbean, but definitely there.

Last time I posted on a similar thread ( a year or so ago) I was able to say that the previous day I'd been at Harrison's and seen, out of maybe 100 users, 2 people of African appearance, 3 or 4 of middle Eastern/ Indian appearance and 3 or 4 of Chinese/ SE Asian appearance.

I wasn't at Harrison's yesterday, but last time I was there, a week or so ago, I saw similar proportions, and usually do when visiting Harrison's or Bowles.

Probably fewer percentage-wise at crags outside the SE, but even so on my last trip to North Wales there were a group of Chinese girls on an adjacent climb that I shared some stances with, and last time at Froggatt I was chatting to a couple of Indian lads.

I'm not disputing that ethnic minorities are under-represented in outdoor climbing, but I don't think they're anywhere near as rare as you make out.
 Postmanpat 24 Apr 2005
In reply to Rob Naylor:
If , as you say , 10 out of 100 users you saw at Harrisons were from minorities wouldn't that almost exactly represent the proporion of ethnic minorities to the total population ? (the total not the breakdown).

Maybe Terry Tullis could stand at the car park policing entry on the basis of colour and bussing in youth groups from Brixton if the quotas were falling short ?
djviper 24 Apr 2005
In reply to Postmanpat: its actulay slightly more than the national % which is just under 9%
unscriptable 24 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach: Does this mean you think you are middle class?
sloper 24 Apr 2005
In reply to djviper: top trolling. How's Dalkey you fecker?
 wizz walker 25 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:
> Is this true?


Having skim read this thread, all I can say is that class is a British disease! Nowhere else, in Europe @ least, have I come across this type of attitude. It smacks of an old Empirical(sp?)order & should be derided @ every available opportunity. Ffs!......, people work OR they don`t?
I know people on benefits who have an income in excess of £30k.
What class are they?
I know people who work in London who earn £100k+.
What class are they?
I know people who work in Chesterfield,where I live,who earn £15k.
What class are they?



djviper 25 Apr 2005
In reply to sloper: thanks sweatness and hows you this morning
AliceW 25 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:

This topic has been done many times before.

I personally know several people of black or asian origin who climb.

In any case, why does it matter?
djviper 25 Apr 2005
In reply to AliceW: i know what you mean at the end of the day it doesnt matter what class colour or creed
In reply to coinneach:
> (In reply to JoHNY)
>
> Knob????
>
> I have rarely met either a coloured or working class person at a British crag.

How can this be true? most climbers I know are black and blue after a day at the crag

 Drew 25 Apr 2005
In reply to Justin:
I've got a Porsche. No opinion to share but defo, I own a Porsche and I'd like to brag

In reply to djviper:
> (In reply to AliceW) i know what you mean at the end of the day it doesnt matter what class colour or creed

It would only matter if there were some people who wanted to climb but there was some social impediment preventing them. In my opinion the most obvious socially impeded group is the under 18's because of over-protective attitudes and issues to do with legal liability.
Nao 25 Apr 2005
In reply to Rob Naylor et al:
I'm Chinese looking (if you want to assign me an ethnic origin). I don't see what race has to do with climbing, but for the record I think the reason why there are fewer 'ethnic minorities' (and please don't use the term 'coloureds') is because there are fewer non-white people in Britain than white people! I'm sure if you went to Thailand then you'd probably find different proportions of ethnicities in climbers.

Then again, we Chinese are fairly short, and perhaps that has something to do with it...

PS I think I might count as middle class. I went to boarding school, and I don't think that 50k is 'rich'...
elinor 25 Apr 2005
In reply to Alison Stockwell:

I think this is the main point really... And I'm positive there are impediments. Think of all the 'socially excluded groups' that get to go on taster courses or outward-bound weekends, and absolutely love it, but then what happens?

A few, whos faces fit may get encouraged and continue.

I wonder if its something to do with the competitive / individualistic nature of the sport, that we're more focused on enjoying ourselves than putting others at ease?

In reply to elinor:
>
> I wonder if its something to do with the competitive / individualistic nature of the sport, that we're more focused on enjoying ourselves than putting others at ease?

I don't think so. Ethnic minorities are under-represented in hillwalking too, and hillwalking is generally non-competitive.

The outdoor training group I belong to used to be sponsored by Brent council, whose policy was to be inclusive, and we were strongly encouraged to try and appeal to ethnic minorities. Our leader tried very hard to engage the interest of local youth groups without a lot of success. A few did come along but not as many as anyone would have liked. In the end it's up to people to do what they want, and if you target minority groups too much, there's the fear that they will feel uncomfortable or patronised.
 u1jd 25 Apr 2005
In reply to Alison Stockwell: I think Alison haas a valid point, i personally dont give a FU*K what color or class you are from but i feel there is no need to actively encourage ethnic minorities into any activity. Most people will make a choice as to which activity/sport they wish to do. Actively encourage people only leads to a greater sterotyping and detracts from the main focus of the activity for all involved.

Regarding class, well class is absolute Sh*t these days, it means nothing, it cant be defined and certainly cant be used to sterotype anyone

Yorkspud 25 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:
> Is this true?

Well, its not for chavs.
In reply to Drew:
> I've got a Porsche. No opinion to share but defo, I own a Porsche and I'd like to brag
>
> I'v got a porch. It doesnt go very fast but its brilliant at keeping the rain off.
djviper 25 Apr 2005
In reply to Psychopathic_Barbie: i have a pooch barks a lot and looks mean!!
 CJD 25 Apr 2005
In reply to djviper:

I've got a perch: gets cross when you take it out of the fishtank and balance birds on it.
 Rob Naylor 25 Apr 2005
In reply to Nao:
> (In reply to Rob Naylor et al)
> I'm Chinese looking (if you want to assign me an ethnic origin). I don't see what race has to do with climbing, but for the record I think the reason why there are fewer 'ethnic minorities' (and please don't use the term 'coloureds') is because there are fewer non-white people in Britain than white people! I'm sure if you went to Thailand then you'd probably find different proportions of ethnicities in climbers.

I never used the term "coloureds"...I think you're confusing me with someone else.

If you've seen previous posts of mine on this subject when the topic's come up before, you'll find that I'm firmly of the "what does race have to do with climbing?" camp.

The only reason I started noticing race at all at the crag was due to it coming up here about 3 times in as many months a year or two back. The reason I was able to come up with approximate figures from my recent trip to Harrisons was because most of those I saw are regulars there, and I can tick back in my mind and say, "yes, Ras was there, and Navin, and that tall (yes,tall!) Chinese-looking girl I've seen there a few times with her mates, and the bloke from East Grinstead who's there all the time....etc. Locally, it's not that I go around counting up, but that if I make a determined effort I can recall the presence of people who I know or at least see there a fair bit.

On "away trips", the only reason I remembered the "ethnicity" of the Chinese and the Indians was that I was actually talking to them. The crags may or may not have been crawling with other "ethnic minority" climbers, I wouldn't notice. But if I've talked to someone at a crag, I'll remember he was Indian-looking just as well as I'd remember if he was wearing an orange beanie.

Actually, you may be wrong about Thailand. The vast majority of people I've seen climbing out there have been of European appearance: that was brought to my notice by a mate who asked why all the climbers seemed to be "white". That was a few years ago now, though.
virgil 25 Apr 2005
In reply to coinneach:

I`d have to agree with some of the other posters and wonder why would anyone care about this.
F*ck social inclusion policies, let people make their own minds up about how they want to spend their time.
Nao 25 Apr 2005
In reply to Rob Naylor:
Rob - I knew you didn't refer to 'coloureds' - it was the OP. (I did put reply to Rob Naylor 'et al' but maybe that wasn't clear enough.) I heartily agree with most of your posts and I know you're not the type of person to say that.
 Dave Garnett 25 Apr 2005
In reply to Nao:

Tricky isn't it? I'd never dream of referring to someone as 'Chinese-looking', for instance, but then coloured (sic) friends in Cape Town would piss themselves as we tied ourselves in politically correct knots trying to avoid any reference to their colour!

One (very well-known) black (as he prefers to be known) friend suggested that we just settle on darkies and stop worrying about it!
Nao 25 Apr 2005
In reply to Dave Garnett:
I say Chinese looking because I look Chinese. However I'm not from China - I was born in Taiwan, which is country and ideology-wise quite a lot different from China. Having grown up looking this way, I find it easier to say Chinese or Chinese looking than Taiwanese, because ethnicity-wise I'd be classed as Chinese (on the forms they never subdivide by Korean/Thai/Japanese etc), and plus people always get Taiwan confused with Thai/Thailand and I can't be bothered to keep explaining. However I think it is kind of a disservice to go around referring to myself as Chinese, when I'm not.

As for 'coloureds', lots of people would find that very offensive. I guess it's all down to your relationship with the person. The bloke and I might joke about it, but I would take a dim view of anyone who started referring to me as 'chinky' or 'nip' or 'coolie' etc, just as others wouldn't like 'paki' or 'nigger' or 'spic'. We do laugh at political correctness but I reckon it's probably better to be too politically correct than offensive.
In reply to coinneach:

Guessing you're in scotland? I don't think I knew of any non-white climbers when i lived in the lakes. Know a few now I live in Coventry though.
 Drew 26 Apr 2005
In reply to Psychopathic_Barbie:

my porsche does go very fast but it doesn't keep the rain off. I can't help thinking there is something wrong here but how many cars do you know with a swimming pool in the back?
<slosh>
 biscuit 26 Apr 2005
In reply to brothersoulshine:
> (In reply to coinneach)
>
> Whether what you're saying is true or not, the real question is - who gives a flying f*ck?


Maybe we need to. Look what happened to non-inclusive NT guided walks.
We might be banned for ever unless we bring a working class/minority ethnic along with us!!
AliceW 27 Apr 2005
In reply to biscuit:

What did happen?
 Postmanpat 27 Apr 2005
In reply to biscuit:
Always keep a flat cap and a packet of Woodbine in your sack .Talk about the mill a lot . Usually fools them .
catbaiter 27 Apr 2005
In reply to Dave Garnett:

Reminds me of a Sri Lankan friend of mine (who will remain nameless).

I took him walking in North Wales on a particuarly miserable Febuary day a few years ago. After ambling up the Pyg Track I felt that we didn't have quite the right kit (we were just sharing a small rucksack with a few bits and bobs in it, that he was carrying) to cope with the compated snow on Snowdon and decided to meander down the Miners Track and called it a day. On the way down my friend, in his London accent, just came out with "This really is a white boys sport isn't it Tom?" I was a bit shocked and amused, and started denying it and telling him that everyone goes to the hills and walks/climbs etc... He didn't believe me, and so we continued down the mountain having this discussion.

As we rounded a corner we came across two bus loads of Rotarians struggling up the hill, absolutely every one of them, to a man stared at my friend as we walked past. I was really really pissed off with them, but my friend just shrugged it off. As the last stragglers past us and stared at him, he looked directly at them, inclined his head to towards me and said:

"It's okay mate, I'm his sherpa"

Aside from falling about laughing he had rather proved his point. Luckily as we walked away giggling we bumped straight into an asian family (can I say that?) also walking up Snowdon, so that shut him up.

New Topic
This topic has been archived, and won't accept reply postings.
Loading Notifications...