In reply to fishy1: I think Dave Macleod's new book has had a bit of an easy ride and lots of good free advertising so far, so I'll offer up my views after finishing the book
From a crap but slowly improving climber.
GOOD POINTS: It’s written by a top climber who practices what he preaches.
The training information is based on scientific principles and sports science research.
The sections where Dave talks about learning falling above trad gear and trad leading tactics are, unlike any other training book I've read, relevant to climbing in the uk.
The style is like a psychological scalpel - direct and to the point in highlighting where your weaknesses lie. If, after reading '9 out of 10..', you still can't figure out the principles you need to follow in order to improve then there's little hope for you.
It gives an overall perspective on training without going too much into details but there are still loads and loads of really useful tips gained from experience on the little details of training for climbing.
BAD POINTS: For me, the book is badly, almost haphazardly, laid out. It isn't an attractive book to look at or read. I found myself wondering if getting it published in time for Christmas release contributed to it's rough look.
Compared to Self Coached Climber '9 out of 10..' doesn't flow nearly as well from one chapter to the next. SCC's chapters build on what is written previously whilst still managing to make it an easy book to dip in and out of to review specific points; '9 out of 10..' doesn't do this for me.
One reason it's hard to dip in and out is due to the poor layout - there aren't any chapter headings on the pages and there are so many sub-headings that it's hard to orientate whereabouts in the book certain bits of information are, also there aren't any pictures or diagrams to illustrate any of Dave's points about technique.
Where SCC uses good quality diagrams, photos and a dvd to illustrate how balance works and the technique drills, '9 out of 10..' is the equivalent of your partner saying 'use your feet' without really showing you how.
The writing style – some of the writing is cut and pasted from past entries on Dave's blog, so the book reads a bit like a series of blog entries which have been re-arranged to give the appearance of progressing from one stage of learning to the next. For me it doesn't work and after getting past the first chapter I felt like the book was starting to repeat itself a bit too much.
I kept finding myself thinking that I was just reading about the same principles of (for want of better words) 'self-awareness' and 'objective self-criticism' over and over but written in a slightly different way in each section to describe whatever the section was about. Maybe I'm self-aware enough already (I should know if I am) but I think anyone with a bit about them would realise that any self-help type book would essentially tell you the same thing (in a different context) as '9 out of 10..' does - that it's all about recognizing your own negative ingrained habits, preconceptions, focusing on the correct things and developing the self-discipline to follow through on initial good practice.
Despite the bad points for me, I'd still recommend '9 out of 10..', but only after buying Self Coached Climber first, I still think the chapters on technique training, movement initiation, balance, strength/endurance/power endurance, training programs and movement learning in Self Coached Climber are the best I've read for nuts and bolts details and '9 out of 10..' makes a good complement which gives you the bigger picture on why you shouldn’t get bogged down in the details.
Pete.