In reply to Voltemands:
> A) are still regularly involved in the sport
Depends what you mean by "regularly", sadly so many have fallen by the wayside (not literally). Changes of location, gf, marriage, children, work, the multitudinous clamour that dissolves your climbing time like caustic acid. So sad
> B) participated in climbing for less than a year and gave it up
None really that I can think of. I think I only remember people who I see quite a few times, so they tend to be pretty keen on the sport. Its worth bearing in mind that I probably wouldn't trust someone who had been climbing for a few weeks to hold my rope(s) on anything outside. I think people who try out a new sport every 6 months are also perhaps outside of my social circle so I wouldn't bump into them so much.
> C) participated in the sport medium term (~5 years ) and gave it up
Perhaps not "gave it up" but certainly I know plenty of people whose commitment waned and they went back down the grades until they only climb very rarely. When you get weak and crap after not going for a while and can't climb hard, it makes it harder to motivate yourself to climb at all... a vicious circle that is all too common
> D) participated in the sport long term (~10 years) and gave it up
I think most people I know who have climbed for 10 years are still climbing. After 10 years, if you do take a break, I think perhaps all that time makes you a bit more resilient to dropping down the grades like a stone and getting depressed about it.
I have spoken to people who have given up because they were too old or got a serious injury that destroyed climbing for them.
> E) participated long term and now only dip in and out of the sport, very irregularly
I don't know many, though I'm sure there are plenty. My regular partners tend to be similar in grade to me (or at least able to second) and similar or a bit younger in age. Guys in their 60s who enjoy vs/hs/vdif occasionally are not really in my peer group.
> F) sadly exited the sport in an unfortunately, involuntary way
Havn't yet known a climber well who was IRL permabanned due to the sport(knock on wood).
Know masses of people who have had very serious injuries but it rarely seems to stop them. Generally they might drop some grades or go for safer routes or take a while recovering but they always come back for more.
> I also understand that there are so many facets to our sport, from gym climbing too FA's of huge faces, in the back side of nowhere, but incorporating inter-sport movement would make things even more complicated...
>
> Thanks for your opinions or tales
I'm not sure you will get a useful body of information from this thread. Different groups of climbers are going to have very different replies and it's worth bearing in mind a few things which will massively bias your results:
- Longtime climbers who only participate rarely now might well be in their 60s as may be most of their partners and peer group. This demographic is not known for their time spent hanging out in online forums!
- People who take up the sport for less than a year may well never get involved with many regular and more experienced climbers so people who reply on this forum (who are likely quite into the sport) will not know these short term climbers even though there may be plenty out there.
- Having been a climbing instructor I would say there are masses and MASSES of people who do one taster/beginners course at an indoor wall and never climb again (big up for our teaching, huzzah!
) and a similarly large number who come a handfull of times and stop after that. I didn't really include them in my answers because I couldn't say that I really "knew" them well and I wouldn't consider them to be climbers, just people who have climbed a couple of times.
Hey, there is a good question - how many times do you have to climb to be a climber? Or is it a state of mind? ;D