In reply to Bruce Hooker:
I understand that you live in the Paris area where perhaps things are a little different, but in my experience the 'average' British driver is worse than the average French driver on a number of accounts. Number one I have done a lot of cycling in both Britain and France and French drivers show vastly more care and consideration when around cyclists. When I was last in the UK it seemed that every other driver was using a mobile phone and whilst you do see people on a mobile whilst driving here you do so much less often. I have found that there is much less of the aggressive 'dodging and weaving' which is such a feature of driving on UK roads with motorists using filter lanes even when they are going straight on and the jumping the lights to get ahead as the 'Traffic light GP' sets off and so on. People here actually seem to stop at red lights! In the UK these days it seems a light is not held to actually be red until 3 or 4 cars have driven though it! The official figures I have read for the number of drivers involved in crash who are over the legal blood alcohol limit clearly indicate that drink driving is now significantly less widespread in France than in the UK. (Ten years ago they were about equal). In fact the UK is the only country in Europe other than Spain to have seen a rise in drink-drive related fatalities in the last 10 years!
The level of 'hit and run' offences in France is also a fraction of the UK's. In France around 3% of crashes are 'hit and runs'. In the UK it is now about 18% and in some areas the figure is over 50% of all crashes resulting in death or serious injury! This is one reason why I am so concerned about all the Brits over here who are on the road illegally as I just can't help wondering whether if one of them ran me down or one of my family they wouldn't be tempted to maintain what is becoming a great British tradition and drive off so as to avoid prosecution.
As to the relative casualty figures. Although the figures for UK vehicle occupant deaths have been much lower than those for France for a long time the gap is now much closer with 4,500 in France as opposed to 3,200 for the UK. Also the figure for UK vehicle occupant
injuries is actually higher than that for France, as are the death and injury rates for vulnerable road users, especially children. The 'low' UK vehicle occupant casualty figures is overwhelmingly a reflection of the high level on congestion on UK roads which has a natural traffic calming effect, not better driving standards! (The paper "Death and injury from motor vehicle crashes: a public health failure, not an achievement" published in the journal
Injury Prevention in 2001 gives a good over-view of this effect). In comparison France is a large country with a much lower traffic density, something which encourages higher speed driving and so more fatal crashes. There are also more cars on the road in France than the UK. The UK's vulnerable road users casualty figures are amongst the worst in Europe and the only reason they aren't even worse is that so few cycle or allow their kids to cycle or walk to school anymore because of the danger posed by 'the traffic'!
Another thing I like about France is that most drivers here seem to have accepted the new robust approach to dealing with driving crimes. If a similar thing was tried in the UK the motor lobby, the right-wing press and so on would be up in arms claiming that there was a 'war on the motorist'. It's no wonder Britain hasn't been able to introduce random breath testing and still has an 80 mg/100 ml drink drive limit!
I would admit one point. I feel that the sort of ex-pat British motorists I have come across, moaning about drink-drive testing, scheming how to avoid having to take out a French licence and so serve a ban when caught going way over the speed limit, driving UK registered cars without insurance and all the rest might well represent 'biased sample' of 'The Great British Motorist'. Most Brits I have come across (and I do try to avoid them!) are the sort of 'done well for themselves', selfish, arrogant 'Daily Mail Reader' types who back in the UK would be getting all indignant about being caught speeding and ranting on about the supposed 'persecution of the beleaguered motorist'!