In reply to El-Mariachi: Orton's a big village round those parts!
The Eden Valley is awesome if a bit 'local'.
Appleby or the cavemen from Kirkby Stephen for a night out. Either way take a deep breath... Last time in Appleby I struggled to find a decent pint anywhere, definitely going down hill.
Climbing in the Eden Valley is limited, your looking at 30 mins from Orton for limestone: King's Meaburn, Windmore End, Murton Crag etc. Access to the Lakes is OK in the sense you are close to the Motorway. Nearest crag is Gouther probably in about 30 mins, anything else is an hour or so.
Tebay/Orton can be a little bit bleak in the winter months.