In reply to owena:
As you will no doubt understand now, if not before, there is no shoe that can do really well on fell, trail and road, every shoe is a compromise.
Do you go for a specialist in one area ( eg mudclaw, or x-talon ) and suffer more in the other areas, or go for the best all rounder ? Only you can answer - if you do 90% fell and 10% road then get a fell shoe, etc
If you decided to go for an all-rounder then one that's not been mentioned is the Salomon Fellraiser. Pretty aggressive sole for fells, 6mm drop ie not too high, drains well, but a bit of cushioning as well for trail/road. They get good reviews, not tried them myself, but definitely on my list for the future.