In reply to toad:
> I think I'm with you on this. It's been sold as the only christmas song it's ok to like, but it's a really bleak song about mutual abuse with no redemption or light at the end.
well, yes, but those lyrics...
"I could have been someone"
"Well so could anyone"
and the way they are delivered- hairs rising on the back of my neck recalling it, and i've heard it dozens of time. it tells a truth about the world in the way that good art does- and that's what i think this is. the fact that its wrapped in shiny christmas paper makes the contrast and emotional depth of the song that bit greater- a masterpiece
but in keeping with Lemming's spirit, my nomination for christmas songs i just don't like would be the one by McCartney- smug, loaded with cliches, and devoid of any real emotion, or point.