/ FRI NIGHT VID: Live Premiere of Adam Ondra's Silence
What time is it starting?
Brilliant ending! I guess the future of world sport climbing is in that cave.
Wow! What a fight
I really enjoyed that! Excellent film.
My first comment is - I have only watched a mere fraction of it so far - what a superb interviewer! ... And sadly (again, so far!) what a soggy audience. I was amazed they didn't respond, let alone clap, after Ondra's first eloquent statement about the 'art' of climbing harder and harder.
I was actually a bit disappointed with the interview, I found myself impatiently waiting for the film. Which was breathtaking - especially that final shot.
> .....what a soggy audience. I was amazed they didn't respond, let alone clap, after Ondra's first eloquent statement about the 'art' of climbing harder and harder.
One possible reason, Gordon, is that perhaps the majority of the audience didn't speak English, at least not to the level required to keep up with Ondra and the interviewer, who were both completely fluent. Jerry's English wasn't bad either....
Have I missed something? The film is fascinating but seems to be only 17 minutes long and doesn't feature the full ascent?
Ye was disappointing as climbing films go.
Ah, good point. Where was the premiere?
Skipped the interview but enjoyed the film, great audio on the climb footage.
I thought the film was great (haven’t watched the interviews yet) and really showed the lengths he went to for success.
It would be interesting to know what’s above Silence, looks like plenty of room to extend the route in future if anyone was ever strong enough.
Yeah I felt the same, had to go back and watch the ascent again cause I assumed it was gonna be a failed attempt as part of the story. Beautiful film though, the last shot was incredible. The background to the ascent probably adds some fuel to the fire of the 9th grade being compressed when you compare how quick Ondra climbs 9b’s...
And that last shot clearly showed that this route is just the warm up for the mega extension!
> The background to the ascent probably adds some fuel to the fire of the 9th grade being compressed when you compare how quick Ondra climbs 9b’s...
Does anybody know whether skipping a grade has ever happened in the past when people have been opening up new grades? i.e. Did anyone ever claim, say, an 8a when the hardest route in the world at the time was 7c?
I guess the question could apply to other grade scales too. Did anyone ever jump over an E-grade because they thought they'd exceeded the existing standard so much? I always wondered whether Dave MacLeod's refusal to grade Echo Wall sprang partly from thinking that perhaps it should be E13 but that wouldn't be accepted. Speaking of which, has anybody shown any interest in repeating it yet?
I think there's an argument Ben Moon opened Hubble at 8c+ when later consensus is that it's 9a. At the time 8c was the hardest grade. So in theory he did make the double grade jump but didn't declare it?
The only time some has proposed multiple grade jumps in climbing (that I can think of) is Tim Emmett and Will Gadd (I think?) climbed a water ice route with horizontal ice and proposed something like WI10 when the current max was WI6... Im a bit fuzzy about the details ...
I found this video insanely impressive. Most times when watching wads climbing it's super relatable because they're basically doing the same thing on steeper rock with smaller holds but watching this was like watching an entirely separate activity to what I call climbing
Dunno if Tony Yaniro on Grand Illusion at 5.13b might be an example. That was *the* historical breakthrough - in terms of tactics & attitude he essentially invented modern sport climbing there & then, even though the route was done on removable gear.
> I think there's an argument Ben Moon opened Hubble at 8c+ when later consensus is that it's 9a.
Ondra suggested 9a. Has anybody else?
Small point - I'm fascinated as to why he climbs in a different shoe on each foot. Are the left/right footholds/heelhooks so different as to require different shoes, or is it just a psychological/comfort thing?
Big point - the first 50 minutes. Er, why?
https://www.ukclimbing.com/forums/ukc/is_hubble_the_world's_first_9a-489992 - In the comments someone also suggested Dave Graham thought it was 9a.. but tbh i thought more people had agreed. Maybe not?
> In the comments someone also suggested Dave Graham thought it was 9a.. but tbh i thought more people had agreed. Maybe not?
Didn't know about Dave Graham. Megos seemed cagey on the grade, can't remember his words but he was pretty clear that AD is harder in his opinion, whatever that means. Not sure about others.
I'll have a read of that thread, thanks.
Slightly derailing things, but found this out about Dave Graham...
"Born in 1981 and originating from Maine, New England he started climbing in 1997 at the age of 16. Within a year he had climbed the US grade of 5.14a (F8b+)"
Amazing progression. Pity he was a late starter.
> The only time some has proposed multiple grade jumps in climbing (that I can think of) is Tim Emmett and Will Gadd (I think?) climbed a water ice route with horizontal ice and proposed something like WI10 when the current max was WI6... Im a bit fuzzy about the details ...
Oh, yeah, that crazy spray ice cave by the waterfall. I remember it but hadn't remembered the massive grading jump. Looked it up and you're spot on. It was Tim Emmett and Will Gadd, they called it Spray On and graded it WI10 which was apparently three grades harder than the hardest existing ice grade. Presumably they were grading it by comparison with mixed or dry-tooling grades.
Interesting. That hint led me to this list of "firsts" through climbing history.
Looks like Grand Illusion and the previous hardest route both get given slash grades so whether or not it jumped a grade depends on how you interpret those.
According to that list, nobody did a 9a+ between 9a and 9b (though the 9b in question is Akira, which I realise is controversial on several levels!).
> Small point - I'm fascinated as to why he climbs in a different shoe on each foot. Are the left/right footholds/heelhooks so different as to require different shoes, or is it just a psychological/comfort thing?
The former, I think. It's not all that uncommon for serious types who spend ludicrous amounts of time working a route or problem to find that mismatched shoes work best. I've seen it in videos a few times. Specifically, I can remember James Pearson doing it on The Groove.
Begs the question, why isn't Megos doing any of this routes if he onsighted 9a years ago? Seems like Ondra is all on his own in this trail blazing journey, which makes it even more impressive as it shows a lot of mental fortitude and true vision
Maybe he's not into spending months or more on a single route? My top redpoint grade is probably 2 grades down from what I might have achieved were I to have been more focused on longer-term redpointing, and I certainly don't regret having had other priorities with that time rather than chasing big redpoint numbers. Each to their own.
Alex Megos has publicly mentioned in his dislike of long-term projects, but perhaps he will change his opinion as he gets older and start knocking out the really big numbers.
Looks like it does need a 2nd pitch!
Mountains on Stage is coming back in April in the UK. With nine cities in total, starting with Edinburgh on April 16, the... Read more
The Montane Spider Hoodie is an all new lightweight and technical alpine hooded fleece pull-on designed for climbers, by... Read more
UKClimbing and UKHillwalking are proud to announce the winners of the 2017 Marmot Photography Awards. An automatic selection of... Read more
In 2015, Austrian Barbara Zangerl and Swiss climber Nina Caprez made the third and fourth ascents of Beat Kammerlander's historic... Read more