In reply to Andy Hyslop - UKClimbing.com:
Aviemore seems to be in direct competition with Fort William to be the Outdoor Capital of Scotland (the UK ?).
Lochaber stole a march on Aviemore with the cycling on Aonach Mor which seems to be a success. Why not develop another venue and try to establish a circuit in Scotland ?
Why not develop an indoor snow sports venue of their own along the lines of the Ice Factor and Xscape at Braehead ? Given the unreliability of conditions in winter in Scotland and the all round popularity of winter sports I think we could sustain them. We couldnt get a single booking one Thursday in February in the Ice Factor. Its a prime example of excellence.
Is Glenmore being utilised to its maximum potential for the benefit of the area ? Is it too inward-looking and 'specialist' ? Its great to have a recognised centre of excellence but could it be more ?
Is the idea of the two areas combining resources to create an Outdoor Executive idealist / impractical ? Create a co-ordinated , joined-up approach ? We're not great at that in the UK. Would it just be a talking shop ? Has the National Park brought real benefits ? Should it be reveiwed ?
Personally, both FW and Aviemore can be a little dismal to visit, lacking character and attractiveness. If I didnt have a strong reason to go there (the excellent walking and mountaineering oppotunities) would I really go ? How are they going to attract those who dont share that interest ?
FW wins de facto with Ben Nevis, which will always bring loads of tourists. And the WH Way, too. Could Aviemore develop a route of equivalent status ? Does the Speyside way measure up ? A Central Highlands Way going thru Glen Nevis, by Loch Ossian, over the Bealach Dubh, out by Loch Ericht, round Meall Chuaich and down to the Ruthven barracks ?
And a National Trekking Centre based on Glens Tromie and Feshie and Geldie and Tilt and Avon and the Lairigs Ghru and an Loaoigh ? A formal hut network, in conjunction with the SYHA or MBA ?
These are just ideas, both general and more detailed to provoke a debate, either here or in Aviemore circles. I'm not saying I'm necessarily pro or anti.
ahunter