In reply to tobyfk:
> (In reply to Mick Ryan - UKClimbing.com)
>
> Is it me or has age and weight-gain rendered the great man a tad more comprehensible? Or has he been ruthlessly edited into shape?
A decade or so ago, he was the token hard core climber at the Mountaineering Literature Festival, then held at Bretton Hall. He was lined up to do a schoolboy type exam in the form of an assigned essay. I was cringing and I'm sure many others were. It just seemed an embarrassing gimmick (albeit a bold one). Off went Johnny like some demented schoolboy leering at his nubile invigilator. And an hour or two later, back he came with a confused wad of scribbles.
F*ck me, it was brilliant! Absolutely brilliant. Searingly raw, nothing held back. None of the insulation that we wind around ourselves to keep the horrors at bay. Yes, of course it needed rewriting and editing. But it was brilliant.
Like many others, I struggle to understand much of what he's trying to say. And I certainly didn't understand everything that he said that day. But any honest person in the room would have had to admit that they were in the presence of genius. It may have been flawed, sporadic, even bloody irritating at times. But it was genius.
I accept that none of this answers your question, Toby. Has the genius deepened, matured, even mellowed? Or has it faded... or simply vanished? I don't know - but I'm more than willing to give the man the benefit of the doubt.
Mick